Comparing Top Dividend Tax Rates in G-10 Countries

The top dividend tax rate is currently 15% in the U.S. This 15% dividend tax rate is applicable to Qualified Dividends earned by all investors who fall in the 25% to 35% ordinary income tax range. Unless Congress takes action, the dividend tax rate is set to jump to the ordinary income tax rates on January 1, 2013. For people in the highest income tax category, this would mean a dividend tax rate of 39.6%.  When changes due to the Affordable Care Act and the re-introduction of the Pease limitation on itemized deductions are included, the top marginal dividend tax rate will reach 44.6% for those in the highest income tax brackets.

Click to enlarge

Comparison of Top Dividend Tax Rates among G-10 Countries:

 

 

Source:  Economic Research, Global Data Watch, October 5, 2012, J.P. Morgan

As shown in the chart above, the U.S. may end up having the highest dividend tax rates among the G-10 countries next year the current dividend tax rates are not extended.

Similar to the tax rate on dividends, the capital gains tax rate is also set to jump from the current 15% to 25% for those in the highest tax-brackets.

The research note from J.P. Morgan notes that one of the impacts of the rise in tax rates would be companies may opt to implement more share buybacks and pay fewer dividends to shareholders. Share buybacks is one of the worst  unproductive strategies followed by mostly U.S. companies that do not benefit shareholders for the most part. Hence investors may face a double whammy next year if dividend tax rates increase. This is because companies may not only pay fewer dividends but also waste excess earnings on buying back their own shares.

The Five Best and Worst Performing Foreign Banks YTD

Some of the emerging equity markets are performing well this year when compared to developed markets. Among the BRIC countries, India is the top performing market so year-to-date (YTD). Despite a growing economy, Brazil is lagging relative to other emerging countries due to political interference in certain sectors of the economy. Argentina is also under-performing due to political instability.  The YTD returns of select countries based on the MSCI indices are listed below:

  • Brazil: -5.55%
  • Russia: 9.06%
  • India: 21.25%
  • China: 12.04%
  • USA: 13.99%
  • Germany: 21.06%
  • UK: 8.95%

Accordingly Brazilian and Argentinian financials are in the negative territory YTD while financials from India have grown by double digits.

The five worst performing exchange-listed foreign bank ADRs YTD:

1.Company: Banco Macro (BMA)
YTD Change: -22.56%
Current Dividend Yield:  N/A
Country: Argentina

2.Company: Itau Unibanco (ITUB)
YTD Change: -21.50%
Current Dividend Yield: 4.21%
Country: Brazil

3.Company:BBVA Banco Frances (BFR)
YTD Change: -14.17%
Current Dividend Yield: N/A
Country: Argentina

4.Company:Banco Santander Brasil (BSBR)
YTD Change: -11.55%
Current Dividend Yield: 3.55%
Country: Brazil

5.Company:Banco Bradesco (BBD)
YTD Change: -5.28%
Current Dividend Yield: 3.72%
Country: Brazil

The five best performing exchange-listed foreign bank ADRs YTD:

1.Company:Lloyds Banking Group (LYG)
YTD Change: 65.61%
Current Dividend Yield: N/A
Country: UK

2.Company:National Bank of Greece (NBG)
YTD Change: 62.63%
Current Dividend Yield: N/A
Country: Greece

3.Company:ICICI Bank (IBN)
YTD Change: 53.61%
Current Dividend Yield: 1.46%
Country: India

4.Company:HDFC Bank (HDB)
YTD Change: 43.57%
Current Dividend Yield: 0.63%
Country: India

5.Company:Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS)
YTD Change: 42.23%
Current Dividend Yield: N/A
Country: UK

Note: Dividends and price changes noted are as of Oct 22, 2012

Disclosure: Long BBD, ITUB, BMA, LYG

Why Invest in Equity Markets

Investors should invest for the long-term and should not try to time the markets. This is especially important for retail investors who lack the time, effort and information necessary to trade for short-term gains. Even most professional money managers with access to powerful tools and better information rarely perform better than the benchmarks.

Equity markets do not always go up in a straight line in any country. There will be bull markets followed be bear markets and the cycle will continue. The following chart shows the performance of the MSCI World Index from 1970 to 2001:

Click to enlarge

 

Source: Why Stock Market Investment?, Royal Skandia

The number of bull markets far exceeds the number of bear markets as shown in the chart above. In addition, the gains produced during bull markets far exceed the losses produced in down markets. Hence investors that stay invested for the long-term get rewarded well for their patience.

For example, though U.S. stocks had a lost decade from Dec 31, 1999 through Dec. 14, 2009 with the S&P 500 losing 23%, smart investors who invested in dividend stocks would have better returns. Choosing stocks with yields of about 3% would have produced a decent return in the “lost decade” due to the effect of dividend reinvestment and compounding.

From a recent article on UK stocks:

For instance, looking at the past 14 years, it could be argued that the FTSE 100 has delivered zero capital returns, with the index being at exactly the same level as it was in February 1998.

The only return, apparently, is from dividends of around 3-4% per annum, which when compounded gives a total return of around 70% over the period.

Hence though the overall stock market goes nowhere during a specific period, investors can still do well by building a portfolio of high-quality dividend stocks and reinvesting the dividends.

Ten foreign stocks to hold for the long-term are listed below with their current dividend yields:

1.Company: Empresa Nacional de Electricidad SA (EOC)
Current Dividend Yield: 3.31%
Sector: Electric Utilities
Country:Chile

2.Company: DBS Group Holdings Ltd (DBSDY)
Current Dividend Yield: 5.75%
Sector:Banking
Country: Singapore

3.Company: Administradora de Fondos de Pensiones Provida SA (PVD)
Current Dividend Yield: 6.43%
Sector: Investment Services
Country: Chile

4.Company: Toronto Dominion Bank (TD)
Current Dividend Yield: 3.76%
Sector: Banking
Country: Canada

5.Company: National Grid PLC (NGG)
Current Dividend Yield: 5.52%
Sector: Electric Utilities
Country: UK

6.Company: Telefonica SA (TEF)
Current Dividend Yield: 9.82%
Sector: Telecom
Country: Spain

7.Company: Banco do Brasil SA (BDORY)
Current Dividend Yield: 4.08%
Sector: Banking
Country: Brazil

8.Company:Cpfl Energia SA (CPL)
Current Dividend Yield: 6.44%
Sector:Electric Utilities
Country: Brazil

9.Company: Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZBY)
Current Dividend Yield: 5.45%
Sector: Banking
Country: Australia

10.Company:EDP Energias de Portugal SA (EDPFY)
Current Dividend Yield: 8.53%
Sector:Electric Utilities
Country: Portugal

Note: Dividend yields are as of Oct 19, 2012

Disclosure: Long TD

Why Volatility Also Matters

Diversification of assets is an prudent way to reduce risk in a portfolio. While the concept of diversification is important volatility is another factor that investors should focus on to generate higher returns.

Why does volatility matter?

The table shows the performance of two sample portfolios with both having an initial investment of $1.0 million:

[TABLE=1144]

Both the portfolios have an average return of 0% in two years. However Portfolio 1’s value at the end of 2nd year is only $750,000 while Portfolio 2 lost only $10,000 and has a value of $990,000. The reason for the difference in performance is that Portfolio 1 is much more volatile. Portfolio 2’s lower volatility produces a higher compounded return.

So the key takeaway from this post is that if two portfolios have the same average return then the portfolio with the lower volatility will always have the higher end value.

Source: Why Volatility & Diversification Matters, Stewart Partners, Australia

Volatility in a portfolio can be minimized by avoiding highly volatile stocks such as IPOs, internet sector stocks, biotech stocks, penny stocks, etc.