Why Invest in South African Bank Stocks ?

South Africa is the most developed country in the African continent. With a population of about 48.0 million the country is rich in many mineral resources including gold, diamonds and platinum. The economy’s size is about $555.0 billion and mining is the largest industry. Investors looking to gain exposure to Africa are better off starting with South Africa.

The CIA’s World Factbook states the following on the state of South Africa’s economy:

Growth was robust from 2004 to 2007 as South Africa reaped the benefits of macroeconomic stability and a global commodities boom but began to slow in the second half of 2007 due to an electricity crisis and the subsequent global financial crisis’ impact on commodity prices and demand. GDP fell nearly 2% in 2009 but recovered in 2010-11. Unemployment remains high and outdated infrastructure has constrained growth. State power supplier Eskom encountered problems with aging plants and meeting electricity demand necessitating “load-shedding” cuts in 2007 and 2008 to residents and businesses in the major cities. Daunting economic problems remain from the apartheid era – especially poverty, lack of economic empowerment among the disadvantaged groups, and a shortage of public transportation. South Africa’s economic policy is fiscally conservative focusing on controlling inflation and attaining a budget surplus. The current government largely follows these prudent policies but must contend with the impact of the global crisis and is facing growing pressure from special interest groups to use state-owned enterprises to deliver basic services to low-income areas and to increase job growth.

Though mining is the major sector in the country, I am not a big fan of investing in mining stocks simply because investing in commodities involves extremely high risks and they can be highly volatile. Hence commodity stocks are not for the faint-hearted especially those trying to invest their hard-earned money or investors trying to earn income in the form of dividends. For example, after reaching record-high prices recently, silver fell 30% in just 6 days. Investing in commodities such as silver, gold and diamonds makes sense only when one takes the physical delivery.

However banking is one South African sector that is attractive but is often ignored by international investors.The four biggest banks in the country are FirstRand, Absa, Standard Bank and Nedbank accounting for 85% of the total banking assets. Some of the reasons to invest in South African banking stocks include:

  • The banking sector is highly regulated in South Africa.
  • The sluggish domestic economy is forcing banks to grow in other parts of Africa and some smaller lenders are increasing unsecured consumer lending.
  • South African banks remained strong during the global financial crisis when many developed banks were on the verge of complete collapse.
  • The World Economic Forum recently ranked South Africa’s banking industry as the second safest in the world.
  • The country’s banks are poised to implement the Basel III requirements quickly and smoothly.
  • Most of the South African banks have capital adequacy ratios of at least 13% which is higher than the minimum requirements set by the Bank of International Settlement’s Basel standards.
  • South African banks are expanding in other African countries in the retail market. In the commercial market, they are increasing their services to South African companies that are the biggest investors on the continent except in the oil and gas sector . For example, Standard Bank has licenses to operate in 17 sub-Saharan countries and Nedbank has a partnership with Togo-based Ecobank which has presence in 32 countries. Absa is considering merging  its retail operations with that of Barclays, its major shareholder and thus gain a foothold in Kenya, Tanzania and Ghana. FirstRand has been aggressively expanding in Africa though its investment banking arm, Rand Merchant Bank.
  • The big four banks primarily focus on high earners in the personal unsecured lending market as opposed to poorer South Africans.
  • Since the South African economy is projected to grow about by 3% for the next two years, banks’ Return on Equity(ROE) may reach 20% instead of 25% when the economy was booming. The 20% ROE is much higher than the ROE levels of most European and US banks.

Source:  Are South African banks still a safe bet?, The Banker

The easiest way to invest in South African banks is via the iShares MSCI South Africa Index ETF (EZA). The fund was launched in 2003 and has an asset base of 493.0 million and. Financials account for about one-fourth of the portfolio and all the four banks mentioned above are part of the fund.

Three of the biggest banks trading on the OTC markets are listed below:

S.No.BankTickerMarket Capitalization as of Nov 30, 2012Dividend Yield as of Nov 30, 2012Stock Price as of Nov 30, 2012
1Absa Group LtdAGRPY$11.5 B5.50%$32.18
2Nedbank Group LtdNDBKY$9.30 B4.12%$20.30
3Standard Bank Group LtdSGBLY$9.1 B10.45%$11.85

 

FirstRand Ltd. trades under the ticker FANDF.

Disclosure: Long NDBKY

The Largest 20 Singapore Companies

The STOXX Singapore 20 Index is comprised of the largest 20 companies in Singapore. The components of this index are listed below:

S.No.CompanySector
1CapitaLand Ltd.Real Estate
2City Developments Ltd.Real Estate
3DBS Group Holdings Ltd.Banks
4Fraser & Neave Ltd.Industrial Goods & Services
5Genting Singapore PLCTravel & Leisure
6GLOBAL LOGISTIC PROPSReal Estate
7Golden Agri-Resources Ltd.Food & Beverages
8Hongkong Land Holdings Ltd.Real Estate
9Jardine Matheson Holdings Ltd.Industrial Goods & Services
10Jardine Strategic Holdings LtdIndustrial Goods & Services
11Keppel Corp. Ltd.Oil & Gas
12Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp.Banks
13SembCorp Industries Ltd.Oil & Gas
14Singapore Airlines Ltd.Travel & Leisure
15Singapore Exchange Ltd.Financial Services
16Singapore Press Holdings Ltd.Media
17Singapore Technologies EngineeIndustrial Goods & Services
18Singapore TelecommunicationsTelecommunications
19United Overseas Bank Ltd.Banks
20Wilmar International Ltd.Food & Beverages

 

Source: STOXX

According to FT Market Data, Singapore Telecommunications Ltd (SINGY) has the largest market capitalization at about $43.0 billion. DBS Group Holdings Ltd (DBSDY), Overseas-Chinese Banking Corporation Ltd and United Overseas Bank Ltd (UOVEY) have market capitalizations in the $20-$30 billion range. Some of the other Singapore ADRs that trade on the OTC market include Keppel Corporation Ltd (KPELY), Singapore Airlines Ltd(SINGY), Jardine Matheson Holdings Ltd (JMHLY) and Wilmar International Ltd (WILMY).

The iShares MSCI Singapore Index Fund (EWS) is up about 25% YTD and has a 3.50% annual dividend yield. Financials account for about one-third of the fund’s portfolio.

Disclosure: No Positions

 

Comparing the Performance of Three U.S. Super Banks

Five long years have passed since the global financial crisis hit equity markets worldwide. One of the worst affected sectors was banking.Though the U.S. banking sector has stabilized in the past couple of years only some of the banking stocks have recovered. Many bank stocks are nowhere near the pre-crisis levels and some have totally disappeared. The number of bank failures has declined from previous years but still 50 banks have failed so far this year.

Among the thousands of banks in the country that struggled during the crisis, the U.S. gave preference in protecting the large banks by handing out billions in bailout funds. As a result most of the larger banks have survived intact and the so-called four too-big-too-fail (TBTF) “super banks” actually became much bigger in size laying the foundation for a more severe crisis in the future.

The following chart shows the equity performance of the three super-banks – Bank of America(BAC), JPMorgan Chase(JPM) and Wells Fargo(WFC) – from their peaks reached before the financial crisis:

Click to enlarge

 

 

JPMorgan Chase  and Wells Fargo have recovered strongly compared to Bank of America with both less than 20% from their peaks. Bank of America is the worst performer with its stock price still off 78.1% from the peak.

Bank of America reached a low of $3.14 on 3/5/2009.Yesterday it closed at $9.86 but the peak was $45.03. From a dividend perspective, these banks now pay lower dividends than before the financial crisis. For example, BAC paid $0.64 in dividends for the 3rd quarter of 2008. Currently it pays a name-sake dividend of just $0.01 per quarter. The plunge in dividend amount shows that the bank has a still long way to go before making any meaningful dividend payments. JPMorgan Chase paid $0.30 in dividends for the 3rd quarter compared to $0.38 at its peak. Wells Fargo last paid a dividend of $0.22 relative to $0.34 per quarter in early 2009.

Disclosure: No Positions

The Top 10 ADRs on the NYSE Based on Market Capitalization

The top 10 foreign companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange based on market capitalization are listed below:

[table “117” not found /]

 

Among the foreign banks,  HSBC Holdings plc  (HBC) has the largest market cap. Colombia’s Ecopetrol (EC) has had an exponential growth since listing and its market cap is closer to that of established industry giants BP and Royal Dutch Shell.

Disclosure: No Positions

A Review of the US ETF Industry

The growth of the ETF industry in the U.S. in recent years has been phenomenal. ETF providers have sliced and diced equities, fixed income instruments and other assets into every way possible. Yet still new ETFs continue to launched on a regular basis.

As of October this year, a total of 1,240 Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) were managed by 37 ETF providers.The total assets in these funds equaled a whopping $1.3 Trillion.

Click to enlarge

 

Some of the interesting facts about the ETF industry include:

  • The inverse/leveraged category of funds has the highest number of ETFs at 179 followed by fixed income with 175 funds.
  • For investing in foreign equities, there are 122 ETFs for developed markets, 128 for emerging markets and 48 under the international specialty category.
  • The top three ETF providers are Blackrock (iShares), State Street Global Advisors (SPDR) and Vanguard. These three firms dominate the market accounting for 83% of the US listed ETF market.

The top 10 ETFs by asset size as of October, 2012 are shown below:

 

The presence of two emerging market funds (VWO and EEM) among the top five shows investors’  interest in emerging markets.

Source: ETF SNAPSHOT: October 2012, SPDR

Disclosure: No Positions