Germany vs. USA: A Short Economic Comparison using Three Factors

The German economy is the largest in Europe with population of about 81 million and a GDP of about $3.0 Trillion in 2011. By all measures the German economic growth since the unification with the former East Germany has been a huge success with Bloomberg BusinessWeek magazine devoting a cover story on this topic. The country follows a socialist type of political system and the state imposes high regulations on many industries. For example, a simple street corner coffee bar has to get licensed from multiple agencies and the bar has to pass many strict inspections.

The U.S. economy is about five times the size of the German economy and the current U.S. population is about 313 million. Unlike Germany the U.S. follows a capitalist system where private entrepreneurship and business are given the highest priority by the state and businesses in most sectors operate with the least regulations compared to European countries including Germany.

The German economy is characterized by stability while the U.S. economy goes through boom and bust cycles. As a result, the unemployment rate is lower in Germany than in the U.S.

In this post let us compare Germany and the US using three economic factors:

1) Household Savings Rate:

Historically Germans saved a higher portion lot of their income. This trend continues and the current savings rate stands high at over 12% of disposable income. High savings rate leads to decline in domestic consumption but it does affect the Germany adversely since the German economy is not a consumer-driven economy like in the U.S.

Click to enlarge

The U.S. personal saving rate has been on a downward trend for many years now. After reaching negative rates by some estimates before the financial crisis of 2008, it has rebounded to 3.6% in November, 2012. Relative to Germany’s rate of over 10% this is low.The U.S. used to have personal saving rates of over 10% in the early 1980s and before.

 

2) Corporate Profits vs Wage Growth:

Due to low unemployment rates and a tight labor market due to strict immigration policies, the take-home pay of German workers has accelerated since 2008. German wages grew at about 2.1% per year since 2008. The following chart shows the rise in household income against corporate income:

In the U.S., corporate profits have soared but workers’ wages have declined to disastrous levels. As the follow graph shows, American workers’ wages have been declining almost on a consistent basis since the 1970s and has accelerated after the dot-com bubble burst. The red line in the graph indicates corporate profits and the blue line indicates workers’ wages.

 

3) Growth in real private consumption per capita:

The chart below shows the growth in real private consumption per capita by decade with the exception of the latest decade in select developed countries.  Private consumption remained lower than in the U.S. in period from 2000 to 2007. Even in the 1980s and 1990s U.S. private consumption growth rate was much higher than Germany’s rate. Despite the lower consumption rates in those decades the German economy prospered especially since the reunification. This is because the  German economy depends more on exports of goods and services than domestic consumption. This is in sharp contrast to the American economy which mostly depends on domestic consumption of goods and services.

 

Sources:

Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Can Germany “grow it alone”? (Part 2),  Investment Essentials, November 2012, AXA Investment Managers

2 Comments

  1. I enjoyed the post, especially the term “socialist”, hey this true, and >70% of the whole world tax literature is written in German. It makes rather a big difference if you eat your Bratwurst sitting or standing. 🙂

  2. Thanks for your comment.
    Most of the world tax literature to me looks Greek including the US one.

    I prefer sitting and eating rather than standing and eating.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *