For Higher Returns, Invest In Consumer Staples Than High-Yield Utilities

Consumer staples stocks traditionally have paid moderate dividends and offered slow and steady growth. Utility stocks on the other hand, have high dividend yields and are considered to have higher growth rates.

When it comes to choosing a sector for investment investors are faced with this question: Should I go with consumer staples which pay moderate dividends or should I go with utilities which pay high dividends?. In the long-term the low-dividend yield consumer staples have easily outperformed utilities. Though utilities have high dividends their dividend growth rate tend to be lower. Hence investors looking to invest for the long-term should invest some potion of their portfolio in consumer staple stocks.

In order to confirm the above theory I used two ETFs for the sectors – Select Sector SPDR-Consumer Staples ETF (XLP) and Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLU) to measure against the S&P 500 ETF (SPY). In both the 5-year and long-term returns XLP outperformed XLU as shown in the charts below.

5-Year Return Comparison:

Click to enlarge

SPY-vs-XLU-and-XLP-5-Years

Long-Term Return Comparison:

SPY-vs-XLU-and-XLP-Since-2001

Source: Yahoo Finance

According to Standard & Poor’s data, the 5-year annualized price return for consumer staples and utilities are 6.09% and -1.54%. The difference in returns is not surprising. In the 3-year and 1-year categories also consumer staples beat utilities.

Note: Chart data shown as of Feb 8, 2013

Disclosure: No Positions

Scientific Research and Innovation Grows In Emerging Countries

Scientific research and innovation was dominated by western countries up until a few years ago. The majority of the scientific publications in the world were published by researchers in these countries. However emerging countries are starting to compete fiercely in the field of scientific innovation. According to an article in OECD Observer, globalization and democratization of scientific research and innovation  have especially lead Asian emerging countries to new global hubs of scientific research.

Click to enlarge

Research-by-Country

Source: Emerging innovators, OECD Observer

Only ten years ago China lagged in the field of scientific research.Today it has surpassed Germany and France to become number two in producing scientific  publications in co-operating with partner countries such as Canada, USA and Japan. South Korea has also increased its R&D spending significantly in the past decade and today published more scientific research than Sweden, Russia and Turkey.

The U.S. still ranks the top country in research and innovation as in the above diagram. But China’s jump to number two position is surprising.

A Note on US Oil Consumption

The U.S. is the world’d largest consumer of petroleum products primarily oil. Though the total population is about 330 million, every day millions of barrels of oil are used due to the high dependence on automobile for transportation. In fact, the country  consumed 18.8 million barrels per day (MMbd) of petroleum products during 2011 according to the U.S. EIA.

Here is a graph showing the US consumption of petroleum products from 1980 thru 2011:

Click to enlarge

US_petcop_img

Source: US EIA

Oil consumption has declined since the peak of the global financial crisis as the economy slid into the great recession. Currently the US consumes about about 19 million barrels per day but produces only about 1/4th of that amount. Hence the rest of the oil is imported from other countries making the country highly dependent on foreign oil.

Related stocks:

The Complete List of Integrated Oil Companies Stocks Trading on the NYSE can be found here.

Five European Chemical Stocks To Consider

The EURO STOXX® Chemicals Index is composed of some of the largest chemical firms in Europe. Currently there are 16 components in this index.

The long-term return of the index is shown below:

Click to enlarge

Euro-Stoxx-Chemical-Index

Source: Euro Stoxx Indices

For investors looking to gain exposure to the European chemical industry the companies in the index offer excellent choices.In five years the index is up about 39% in US $ terms.

Five components from the EURO STOXX® Chemicals Index is listed below with their ticker and current dividend yield for further research:

1.Company:Air Liquide (AIQUY)
Current Dividend Yield: 2.35%
Country: France

2.Company: Akzo Nobel NV (AKZOY)
Current Dividend Yield:
Country: The Netherlands

3.Company: Arkema SA(ARKAY)
Current Dividend Yield:
Country: France

4.Company: BASFY AG (BASFY)
Current Dividend Yield:
Country: Germany

5.Company: bayer AG (BAYRY)
Current Dividend Yield:
Country: Germany

Note: Dividend yields noted are as of Feb 11, 2013

Disclosure: No Positions

Proof That Chasing Performance Does Not Work

One of the reasons most retail investors perform so poorly in stock investing is that they tend to chase performance. Investors always go with the hottest theme or stock that driving the markets at any given time. During the late 1990s it was tech stocks, energy and security stocks after the 9/11 attacks, banking and other financial stocks leading up to the global credit crisis,  etc. When more investors chase the same stock or fund or a theme prices go up to unsustainable levels and at some time the mania ends and the bubble bursts.

Investing in markets is about buying low and selling high. Many investors end up doing the opposite by chasing performance. The disastrous effect of chasing performance is shown in the chart below:

Click to enlarge

Chasing-Performance-Bad-Idea

Source: Desparately Seeking Safety, Seth J Masters, Alliance Bernstein

The average stock investor earned less than half of the annualized total returns generated by the S&P 500 from 1992 thru 2011. The average bond investor performed even worse earning less than 1% compared to the U.S. bonds return of 6.5%.

The main reason for the poor performance of the average investor is that they sold stocks and bonds that performed poorly to buy stocks and bonds that performed well. This led them to sell low and buy high.

So the key takeaway from this post is that investors should always stay clear of the hottest trend in the market and instead focus on buying low and selling high.

Related ETFs:

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY)
SPDR Gold Trust ETF (GLD)
iShares Silver Trust ETF (SLV)
United States Natural Gas Fund (UNG)
United States Oil Fund (USO)

Disclosure: No Positions