Comparing the Returns of Russian and U.S. Equities 1865 to 1917

During the 1800s the U.S. was an emerging market. During that time the Tsars ruled Russia and  Russian equities trading on the St.Petersburg Stock Exchange performed better than U.S. equities on the New York Stock Exchange.

Click to enlarge


The above chart shows that Russian stocks vastly outperformed U.S. stocks from 1865 thru 1917. However a couple of fascinating points have to taken into account when reviewing the Russian stocks towards the early 1900s. From July 1914 the St. Petersburg Exchange was shut down due to World War I as denoted by the dotted gray line in the chart above. Then when the market opened in 1917 stocks rallied swiftly by about 20%. But the euphoria was short-lived as the Russian Revolution came along almost immediately. By October of 1917 the Tsarist government was overthrown and communists too control of the country. As a result of the revolution all Tsarist era securities became worthless.

So even though Russian stocks were great to hold from mid 1800s to early 1900s, all of a sudden they all became worthless . The key takeaway from this story is markets can turn upside down without warning due to political upheavals  Hence investors investing abroad have to monitor political developments in addition to company’s financials and macro-economic changes.

Source: Credit Suisse Global Investment Yearbook 2013, Credit Suisse

Hat Tip: The Big Picture

Here is the more recent long-term performance of Russia’s RTS Index vs S&P 500:


Source: Yahoo Finance

Related ETFs:


Market Vectors® Russia ETF (RSX)

Disclosure: No Positions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *